Results of a new user survey on attitudes toward SAP's licensing practices are neither ambiguous, nor surprising -- especially for those already frustrated with the way the software maker does business. The U.K. and Ireland SAP User Group, which conducted the survey, said SAP is listening, even though it's unclear what changes the software maker will eventually make.
According to the survey, which included 366 users among 150 organizations throughout the region, 95% of SAP users believe the company's software licensing policies are overly complicated.
Furthermore, the research revealed users want to see greater transparency when it comes to licensing costs, with 88% of respondents believing that SAP should make its price list public.
Though the numbers will likely surprise few users of SAP software, Philip Adams, the group's vice chairman, said the poll marked only the beginning of a recent initiative by his group to drill down on customers' concerns around licensing and pricing, and to engage SAP on making improvements in those areas. Adams said the group would likely perform a similar poll in another year to see where progress had been made.
At the same time, while the survey didn't address specific complaints as to why SAP's licensing practices were so opaque to so many of its customers, Adams said the problems were not specific to SAP, but were common among software customers in general.
Apart from SAP changing its policies, however, SAP could improve the situation at the sales level by making sure representatives do a better job of explaining the company's current licensing policies and pricing to current and potential customers, and making sure the information on the SAP Service Marketplace is clearer, and easier to find. The SAP Service Marketplace is the main entry point for information on customer support, consulting services, education services and partner support information.
"[SAP has to improve the SAP Service Marketplace] to make it clear, so that if people don't want to get it from their salespeople, they can log onto the website and see how it's licensed," Adams said.
Earlier this year, Gartner released a report on where customers should go for information on SAP products and licensing, which also criticized the SAP Marketplace, among other portals of information.
Finding the right information there can be difficult, said Derek Prior, a Gartner analyst and co-author of the report, due to the fact that the search technology SAP uses within its portals is "ineffective" compared to more commonly known engines like Google.
"SAP's own search technology is just not very efficient," Prior said. He also said confusion over SAP licensing has grown. "The stuff for SAP licensing has gotten so much more complex over time. It's very, very complicated," Prior said.
Other responses around SAP licensing practices were equally pessimistic. The vast majority of respondents said it was difficult to know what licenses they needed through the lifecycle of their SAP software, a problem caused by SAP software packages coming with multiple licenses with different limits regarding usage rights, according to the survey. Approximately 89% of users said they would like SAP to reduce complexity by offering software based on only one licence or usage metric.
The survey also found that customers are looking for more flexibility when it comes to only paying for support on the licenses they're using, given that usage patterns fluctuate over time, and that companies often downsize during challenging economic times, which also affects the number of people using the software. According to the survey, 97% of respondents said they should have the ability to "park" those unused licenses during support periods.
Roughly three-quarters of respondents said they had to buy more licenses or functionality than they actually needed, when all they wanted was specific functionality for a small group.
In a statement provided to the U.K. and Ireland SAP User Group, SAP said it understood users' frustration about the "perceived complexities" around its licensing practices, and were embarking on a number of measures.
Those measures include standardizing terms and conditions globally for all customers, as well as making sure all software rights -- including those for the full Sybase suite -- are available online, according to Tim Noble, managing director of SAP in the U.K. and Ireland.
"We've also spent a significant amount of time on simplifying the buying process so that it's easy to understand, as well as ensuring implementation of SAP's products and services are tailored to meet our customers' individual and specific needs," Noble is quoted as saying in the survey results summary.
When asked if Noble's statement merely suggested SAP was only willing to tinker with the edges of SAP licensing rather than any underlying structure, Adams said he was for now reserving judgment.
"I'll hold my response for at least another six to 12 months. I think it's positive that SAP is willing to engage. Maybe [Noble's] answers are scratching the surface, and are nice to have around the edges. Maybe we'll get into the meat in the future," Adams said. "Maybe the start has been slower than we'd like, [but] I can understand that this takes time."
Tips on how to lower licensing fees for SAP