Problem solve Get help with specific problems with your technologies, process and projects.

JD Edwards shop weighs the options with SAP and Oracle

Executive advice expert Joshua Greenbaum offers his take on the SAP-Oracle slugfest.

For a medium-sized SAP/JD Edwards shop looking to move up from R/3, what approach would you recommend in light of the Oracle-SAP slugfest? Take up SAP on its generous 75% rebate offer, or go with Oracle's new Off SAP program? Either way it sounds like a fairly sweet deal, but I know better than to trust sales reps from either side. Any suggestions for how to get started evaluating the options?
Congratulations on being in the catbird's seat -- you're definitely destined to get a sweet deal, one way or the other. Politics aside, your first duty is to assess which vendor can provide the best functionality specific to your industry and business needs. And the best way to assess their relative value is to talk to customers of each vendor. The closer the customer is to your business and industry the better. My recommendation would be to go through the ASUG user group for SAP and the IOUG for Oracle, just to make sure you're getting the most unbiased opinions possible.

Your other obligation is to really sort out the upgrade and/or migration costs, and try if at all possible to get a fixed bid from each vendor's SI partners. Don't forget training costs in the equation: The number one failure point in an implementation is inadequate training, and when the implementation involves a migration, there's no more important factor than making sure your users can hit the ground running.

Dig Deeper on SAP implementation and upgrades

Have a question for an expert?

Please add a title for your question

Get answers from a TechTarget expert on whatever's puzzling you.

You will be able to add details on the next page.

Start the conversation

Send me notifications when other members comment.

Please create a username to comment.