BAPIs vs. IDocs for Web-to-SAP interfaces, what are the differences?

Which option is better for interface data from a Web site, BAPI calls or IDocs? Read Axel Angeli's expert opinion on BAPIs vs. IDocs for Web-to-SAP interfaces in this expert tip.

Logosworld

We are building custom Web-to-SAP interfaces and I would like to know if it is better to interface the data from our Web site via BAPI calls or by use of IDocs. I understand the advantages and disadvantages of both.

However, are IDocs still a viable long-term option with SAP? I have been told that SAP is moving away from IDocs...

Step 2 of 2:

You forgot to provide an Email Address.

This email address doesn’t appear to be valid.

This email address is already registered. Please login.

You have exceeded the maximum character limit.

Please provide a Corporate E-mail Address.
- I agree to TechTarget’s Terms of Use, Privacy Policy, and the transfer of my information to the United States for processing to provide me with relevant information as described in our Privacy Policy.
Please check the box if you want to proceed.
- I agree to my information being processed by TechTarget and its Partners to contact me via phone, email, or other means regarding information relevant to my professional interests. I may unsubscribe at any time.
Please check the box if you want to proceed.

in favor of BAPIs. In other words, use of IDocs the old way to interface data and the new and preferred way is via BAPIs. Is there any truth to that?

IDocs are still a viable long-term option! The decision between BAPIs and IDocs depends on who will bear the burden of error handling.

BAPI error handling needs to be done by the calling application, while IDoc error handling can be done through BD87, etc. By the way, IDocs are also received through a BAPI: "IDOC-INBOUND_ASYNCHRONOUS." Still, I have no overall preference of BAPIs over IDocs or vice versa. However, if communication can be done asynchronously -- so the caller does not need an answer back right away -- then the IDoc solution is the safer and easier way of doing the work.

This was last published in March 2006

Related Q&A from Axel Angeli

Uploading data to SAP R/3 without enabling SAP Scripting

An SAP user wants to know how to upload data into SAP R/3 when SAP Scripting is not enabled. Continue Reading

Fixing error during SAP iDoc PORDCR1 integration

An SAP user is receiving an error message while integrating SAP iDoc PORDCR1 for a purchase order. Continue Reading

Solving PERNR data transfer issues with SAP PU12 toolbox

An SAP user is having difficulty with PERNR iDoc while transporting data from SAP to an external system. Continue Reading

Have a question for an expert?

Please add a title for your question

Get answers from a TechTarget expert on whatever's puzzling you.

Meet all of our SAP administration / development experts

View all SAP administration / development questions and answers

SearchERP

AI in the workplace will change ERP systems

As AI becomes more embedded in workplace processes and bots, it will learn on the job and eventually become more independent, ...

A complete guide to buying enterprise accounting software

Learn more about the accounting software vendors and products that make up the enterprise accounting software market, which ...

Get to Industry 4.0 with a smart factory roadmap

Creating a smart factory needn't require starting from scratch. Here's advice on how you can create connectivity with the ...

SearchOracle

The future of SPARC/Solaris is cloudy -- in multiple ways

Cutbacks by Oracle have put the future of SPARC and Solaris in doubt, but the vendor says it's still committed to the ...

How Oracle DBA responsibilities change with Autonomous Database

Oracle's Autonomous Database automates basic tasks of database administrators. That may put some DBA jobs at risk, but many will ...

AI-for-IT-operations tools map Vegas systems to Oracle ERP

Mapping IoT activity and other IT data to Oracle ERP is the task Las Vegas set for FixStream's AIOps platform in an effort to ...

SearchDataManagement

Focus, scope and spotting opportunity are key to role of CDO

Chief data officers and experts see the CDO role as changing to a more strategic orientation -- especially finding key ...

Good data quality for machine learning is an analytics must

As companies add machine learning applications, they need to really understand -- and be able to improve -- their data. That's ...

Chief data officer role: Searching for consensus

The chief data officer role is about many things -- regulations, innovation, AI and more. Consultant Randy Bean discussed the ...

SearchAWS

Matt Wood talks AWS' AI platform, ethical use

AWS' AI tools have gained traction with users but also criticism from civil rights advocates. Matt Wood, an AWS deep learning and...

AWS Snowball Edge extends EC2 on premises

AWS Snowball portable data transfer devices gain EC2 functionality, as the public cloud vendor seeks more ways for customers to ...

Assess AWS serverless costs and learn how to reduce them

Serverless architectures help teams deploy to production faster but also introduce an entirely new cost structure. Use this ...

SearchBusinessAnalytics

Data analytics in government efforts lack structure

Data analytics in government agencies lack organization, focusing on immediate problems instead of attacking underlying causes ...

A complete guide to buying data discovery software

Data discovery software turns data into business insights, and it's vital for GDPR compliance. This guide outlines the products ...

Rising demand for business analytics education programs

Colleges and universities are increasingly offering business analytics degrees. The graduates can help build IT and business ...

SearchCRM

Augmented reality in retail transforms customer experiences

Retailers like Hershey's are experimenting with augmented reality to take the customers' experience beyond a smartphone screen ...

Assessing GDPR's data protection officer requirements

The GDPR's data protection officer mandate gives the EU a point person for compliance complaints, but not all companies need one....

Cannabis CRM replicates dealer-customer relationship

When a big-city medical marijuana business wanted to better serve clients, it opted for cannabis CRM software that tries to ...

SearchContentManagement

At OpenText Enterprise World, security and AI take center stage

OpenText unveiled its new application, OT2, at OpenText Enterprise World 2018, while also touting the importance of security. ...

Augmented reality devices speed van repairs at Volkswagen U.K.

Augmented reality headsets for garage mechanics speed collaboration between repair shops and experts in the home office to solve ...

Endpoint security tool fueled OpenText's Guidance Software acquisition

Endpoint security was the primary draw for OpenText's Guidance Software acquisition. But plans to improve e-discovery and data ...

SearchHRSoftware

Cost, doubt about tech hold back AI for HR investment

AI technology will improve the productivity of HR departments by eliminating many routine and transactional processes. But what ...

Health and wellness benefits are exploding; are you keeping up?

A WorldatWork survey shows companies offered a wide variety of health and wellness benefits at an expanded rate last year. Is ...

Automated recruiting solves Groupon's sourcing talent woes

Building a talent pool through effective sourcing is a major effort by Groupon. It is using a recruiting automation tool to find ...

Related Resources

Dig Deeper on SAP interface technologies

Related Q&A from Axel Angeli

Have a question for an expert?

Start the conversation

0 comments

Register

Login

Forgot your password?

Your password has been sent to:

Please create a username to comment.