Home > SAP software/management News > Benefits and tradeoffs of on-demand SAP SRM
SAP software/management News:
EMAIL THIS

Benefits and tradeoffs of on-demand SAP SRM

By Jason Busch, Contributor
04 Nov 2009 | www.spendmatters.com

SAP news, tips and expert advice
Digg This!    StumbleUpon Toolbar StumbleUpon    Bookmark with Delicious Del.icio.us    Add to Google

On-demand versions of SAP Supplier Relationship Management (SRM) provide almost all the same capabilities as the installed version of SAP SRM, except for the ability to customize and configure the system at a truly granular level.

More information on SAP SRM
Learn more about how SAP SRM 7.0 bolsters firms' procurement processes.  

Learn more about the benefits of implementing SAP SRM.  

Get an understanding of the supply process and concepts in SAP SRM.

For some SAP SRM users, this might turn out to be a plus: The more an organization moves toward a completely customized package, the more likely it is to move away from accepted best practices.

Regardless, SAP SRM on-demand can provide a complete solution along the lines of an installed SRM deployment, including the ability to search catalogs, create requisitions, manage approval workflows and order management, receive goods, monitor order status, oversee basic invoicing and approval processes, and reconcile invoices on the back end.

On-demand SAP SRM users can also take advantage of many of the same capabilities that users of other hosted and network-based solutions enjoy, including:

  • Capabilities and services to streamline the supplier enablement process.
  • An online supplier network and connection hub for document exchange and management.
  • Holistic content management capabilities (built around the need for both buyers and suppliers to interact with and take ownership of different types of information).
  • Invoice automation functionality that extends the basic capabilities of core ERP and SRM components.

Considering SAP SRM deployment

Procurement departments and IT organizations should also take into account several deployment considerations in their evaluation process of behind-the-firewall or hosted models. These include deployment costs tied to software and hardware, such as software licenses, database licenses, operating system software, hardware, and hardware installation. They also include costs tied to professional services that an organization would otherwise have to purchase, such as software installation, configuration/customization, implementation services, supplier on-boarding, catalog formatting, and loading.

In performing these calculations, one must consider the time value of money and acknowledge that many installed deployment times are measured in years, not months or quarters. Companies should also factor in recurring supplier management costs, such as automating and managing document exchange (e.g., PO, ASN, invoice), once a system is running.

On-demand procurement-to-pay systems can introduce significant ongoing benefits and savings. In addition to reducing IT overhead and foot-dragging (e.g., "You'll need to wait until next week for that new direct supplier connection"), on-demand SRM systems can provide a lower TCO over a longer timeframe.

On-demand procurement-to-pay systems also deliver a range of soft benefits, from around-the-clock service and support (for buyers and suppliers) to shifting the burden of catalog and content management to a third party rather than making the IT department or procurement organization own a time-consuming process.

Most important, on-demand approaches nearly always accelerate spend under management, as measured by the number of catalogs enabled, the number of suppliers, overall percentage of spend capture, and ongoing reporting and analytics.

In the case of SAP SRM 7.0, customers can take advantage of the latest SAP technology, regardless of which version of SAP ECC they're running on the back end (albeit with some limitations around services procurement and contract management). In today's climate of delayed ERP upgrade cycles, this last point represents yet another reason for companies to explore the on-demand SAP SRM option.

Challenges of an SAP SRM on-demand approach

On-demand approaches to SRM -- and procure-to-pay in general -- come with their own set of challenges. Companies must often reconfigure their own processes to adapt to the customization and configuration limitations of on-demand providers. And when choosing to work with an on-demand provider, risk-averse organizations must find a way to get comfortable with delegating responsibility for key strategic supplier management processes to a third party, not to mention agreeing to limit their choice to work with multiple providers in areas such as supplier enablement, content management, and search.

Taking the on-demand route requires plunging in head-first with a single key provider rather than hedging bets between multiple options and partners. For some organizations, the long-term TCO equation of on-demand providers can actually be higher than for installed software (though in the case of procure-to-pay and SRM, this is rare, given all the external and internal supplier management costs). Finally – and this limitation is critical in complex heterogeneous environments – the on-demand option will also limit integration capabilities relative to highly customized deployments.
Graham Packaging significantly increased the levels of spend it was able to bring under management by migrating from an installed to an on-demand model.

Which companies are best suited to consider the SAP SRM on-demand option? One group is obvious. Any company considering an SRM deployment should at least investigate the on-demand option, examining how it can help overcome many of the supplier enablement and adoption hurdles posed by behind-the-firewall approaches.

Less obvious is the second group of organizations that should consider SAP SRM on-demand: SAP customers already using SAP SRM. Spend Matters research shows that at least one former SAP SRM user, Graham Packaging, significantly increased the levels of spend it was able to bring under management by migrating from an installed to an on-demand model.

Based on this analysis, Spend Matters recommends that:

  • All companies considering an SAP SRM 7.0 purchase or upgrade decision should investigate on-demand options available to them.
  • Organizations should determine whether they are a good fit for an on-demand implementation based on many factors, including organizational and systems structure and complexity.
  • Both procurement and IT evaluate other options to reconfirm that SAP SRM 7.0 (and on-demand) is the right decision.
  • Companies build a business case examining all the cost factors that go into not only an SRM implementation but the ongoing lifecycle requirements of a solution over a three- to five-year timeframe (for both installed and on-demand options).

About the author: Jason Busch is principal analyst at www.spendmatters.com, a blog and research community dedicated to examining spend management issues such as procurement, sourcing, spend analysis and visibility, supply chain and lean techniques. For additional insights on SAP SRM 7.0, visit the Spend Matters site or download the PDF of SAP SRM 7.0 -- The Wait's Over, But Is It Worth It? Making SRM a Total Cost Success in Your Organization -- Background, Tips, Strategies and Tactics (Plus On-Premise vs. On-Demand Costs and Trade-Offs).

Tags: SAP supplier relationship management softwareSAP ROI and TCOSAP support and maintenanceVIEW ALL TAGS

Digg This!    StumbleUpon Toolbar StumbleUpon    Bookmark with Delicious Del.icio.us    Add to Google



RELATED CONTENT
SAP supplier relationship management software
SAP SRM 7.0 bolsters firms' procurement processes
The benefits of SAP supplier relationship management (SRM)
Understanding supply processes and concepts in SAP SRM
Implementing SAP Enterprise Buyer and other SAP supply components
Updating URLs in SAP SRM
How to change default settings in SAP SRM
What are the benefits of implementing SAP SRM?
SAP extends enhancement packages across suite with Business Suite 7
Switching from an extended classic to a classic scenario
Hiding a limit order field from users in SRM 5.0

SAP ROI and TCO
SAP's New Year's resolution: Work more closely with customers than ever
Ray Wang discusses SAP customer priorities in 2010
SAP SRM 7.0 bolsters firms' procurement processes
Running a virtualized SAP environment: Can your hardware handle it?
SAP infrastructure changes to databases, servers yield quick returns
Day & Zimmermann's CIO talks SAP strategy
SAP focusing on delivering SAP best practices in a bad economy
SaaS ERP case study: Asahi Kasei division rips out SAP, deploys NetSuite
Focus on growth, business processes helps users stay afloat in the downturn
Sapphire 2009: SAP will focus on making software easier to use and deploy

SAP support and maintenance
SAP Standard support decision hinges on inflation, fees
Choosing Standard or Enterprise support more difficult for SAP customers with no KPIs
SAP relents on lower-cost maintenance, scraps KPI program
SAP Enterprise Support KPI program works, but too much work for users
As SAP shows 'clear path forward,' some users look to stay behind
SAP postpones maintenance fee hike
SAP users in U.K., Ireland ready to upgrade -- warily
SAP customer happy with third-party maintenance and support
Collaboration a must for SAP hardware teams and software teams
SAP Enterprise Support KPIs open door to negotiating SAP maintenance

RELATED GLOSSARY TERMS
Terms from Whatis.com − the technology online dictionary
supplier relationship management  (SearchSAP.com)

RELATED RESOURCES
2020software.com, trial software downloads for accounting software, ERP software, CRM software and business software systems
Search Bitpipe.com for the latest white papers and business webcasts
Whatis.com, the online computer dictionary



SAP Training & Employment
About Us  |  Contact Us  |  For Advertisers  |  For Business Partners  |  Site Index  |  RSS
SEARCH 
TechTarget provides technology professionals with the information they need to perform their jobs - from developing strategy, to making cost-effective purchase decisions and managing their organizations' technology projects - with its network of technology-specific websites, events and online magazines.

TechTarget Corporate Web Site  |  Media Kits  |  Site Map




All Rights Reserved, Copyright 2000 - 2010, TechTarget | Read our Privacy Policy
SearchSAP.com is a search service provided by TechTarget and is completely
independent of and not affiliated with SAP AG.
  TechTarget - The IT Media ROI Experts